Review Slightly different opinions

Minecraft: Story Mode – reviews and rating

Minecraft: Story Mode has an average rating of 72% based on 32 reviews from English-language gaming websites. Critics have slightly different opinions – the best rating was given by Game Informer (8.5/10), the worst by HardcoreGamer (2.5/5). The game was released on November 16, 2015 for PS3 and Xbox 360.

Updated

What critics praise
„Following a lackluster second episode, Minecraft: Story Mode builds towards something better with Episode 3.“
8,5/10 Game Informer
What critics criticize
„Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode 2: Assembly Required doesn’t meet the bar that the previous episode set, but that doesn’t rule it out as awful.“

Game info

Release date
Nov 16, 2015
Platforms
PS3Xbox 360
Reviews count
32

The best games

Check out the best games of the year 2026 on:

FAQ

What is the rating of Minecraft: Story Mode?

Minecraft: Story Mode has an average rating of 72% based on 32 reviews from English-language gaming websites. Critics have slightly different opinions – the best rating was given by Game Informer (8.5/10), the worst by HardcoreGamer (2.5/5).

When was Minecraft: Story Mode released?

Minecraft: Story Mode was released on November 16, 2015.

What platforms is Minecraft: Story Mode available on?

Minecraft: Story Mode is available for PS3 and Xbox 360.

Is Minecraft: Story Mode worth playing?

Mostly yes. Minecraft: Story Mode has an average rating of 72% – it is a good game, but with some flaws.

What games are similar to Minecraft: Story Mode?

Games similar to Minecraft: Story Mode are for example Life is Strange: Episode 2 - Out of Time, Batman: The Telltale Series, Geometry Wars 3: Dimensions, Dying Light and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2.

Statistics

Critics consensus

Slightly different opinions

Spread of ratings
35 percentage points
Standard deviation
± 8,8
Best rating
8,5/10 Game Informer
Worst rating
2,5/5 HardcoreGamer

The distribution of rating

Number of reviews in rating ranges (%)

Ranking

  • #473 of 717 games released in 2015 better than 34 % of games
  • #20 of 22 games released in 2015 on PS3 better than 10 % of games
  • #12 of 16 games released in 2015 on Xbox 360 better than 27 % of games

By the average of all reviews

Comparison of ratings

  • Critics in this language32 reviews 72%
  • Foreign critics11 reviews 57%

Local critics rate the game higher by 15 %.

Reviews

2,5/5
HardcoreGamer Oct 6, 2016
Being the last episode in the Minecraft: Story Mode story, the episode doesn’t really close out the story of the Order of the Stone as a whole and really only makes it an addition to one of the many adventures that Jessie will have. It seems a little distant from the kind of heroes that the group wanted to be at the closing of the fifth episode, but it could very well be that they aren’t ready for...
3/5
HardcoreGamer Aug 4, 2016
This episode is a step up from the previous one, starting up the halfway point of the Adventure Pass on a much higher note, but it falls short in longevity, proving that a character can be developed and well liked if focused on and given more tie as opposed to adding several characters that don’t necessarily add to the story.  What we really took away from the experience was the rushed feeling of the...
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
8/10
Game Informer Jul 27, 2016
The penultimate episode of this season of Minecraft: Story Mode is the best since the conclusion of the Wither Storm saga.
3/5
HardcoreGamer Jun 23, 2016
While this is a relatively weak episode in the Minecraft: Story Mode world, it isn’t the worst episode and with the addition of the new characters, it will be enjoyable for fans and players alike.  As an overall episode, the story is great but there are a few missed opportunities that Telltale could have taken advantage of to make it much better than what the final product is.  Hopefully, Telltale...
3,5/5
HardcoreGamer Apr 3, 2016
Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode 5: Order Up! shapes up to be an incredible introduction to the Order of the Stone’s newest adventures, but still manages to fall a little short.  Telltale introduces new concepts, characters and worlds, but their biggest mistake was shoving it all into a single episode.  Had they created a separate season talking about the events of Sky City and expanding a little bit...
7/10
Game Informer Mar 31, 2016
Episode 5: Order Up continues the tale of the New Order of the Stone, but this fifth episode doesn’t live up to the gradually building excitement of its predecessors.
7/10
Game Informer Mar 31, 2016
Episode 5: Order Up continues the tale of the New Order of the Stone, but this fifth episode doesn’t live up to the gradually building excitement of its predecessors.
7/10
Game Informer Mar 31, 2016
Episode 5: Order Up continues the tale of the New Order of the Stone, but this fifth episode doesn’t live up to the gradually building excitement of its predecessors.
4/5
HardcoreGamer Dec 29, 2015
Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode 4: A Block and a Hard Place is the strongest episode yet in basically every aspect.  Employing emotional factors as well as hard story elements, Telltale has managed to create a story that originated from just a few blocks.  Every second of this two hour episode was spent towards making the player feel as though everyone really is depending on them to save the world....
4/5
HardcoreGamer Dec 4, 2015
Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode 3 is a mixture of humor and emotion, but never loses itself as being an addition to the original game.  It’s littered with crucial story elements and plot twists that easily makes this the best episode in the series yet.  The episode, depending on your decisions in previous episodes, ends with a cliffhanger that makes you hungry for the next.  It’s as though Telltale...
2,5/5
HardcoreGamer Nov 5, 2015
Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode 2: Assembly Required doesn’t meet the bar that the previous episode set, but that doesn’t rule it out as awful. The fact that it relies on environments to cover the fact that there’s really nothing to do/talk about gives reason as to why forked paths are rarely done in games.  There are no new innovations and because of that, the story should be a little stronger, but...

Videos

Similar games

How is xxx game compared to similar games? Minecraft: Story Mode has been beaten 8 times and is worse than most games compared. Our recommendation - try another game instead.

More games from the series